As medicine targets personal DNA profiles, York researchers examine ethics and patient experiences
Posted on 29 July 2004
The use of genetic testing as a routine part of medical treatment opens exciting horizons, but brings with it the responsibility to understand the concerns individuals may have about DNA sampling, and about wider issues such as the possible impact of genetic information. Much of the science of pharmacogenetics is known, but there are many potential hurdles to overcome before the technology is introduced into routine medical use.
Over the next three years Professor Andrew Webster, Dr Graham Lewis and a team in the Science and Technology Studies Unit (SATSU) at York will work with colleagues across the UK monitoring patients’ reactions to warfarin, commonly used to prevent blood clots. The team from York will interview some of the 2,400 patients who will be selected for the study. Of the 2,400 patients, 2000 will be hospital-based and 400 will be recruited through GP surgeries as warfarin can be prescribed by GPs.
Patients’ responses will be mapped against their personal DNA profiles and the SATSU team will interview them to see how they feel about DNA samples being taken, and how publicly acceptable this would be, and the hurdles to introducing the technique.
Warfarin is a very useful drug currently taken by 600,000 patients in the UK, but a small proportion of those who take it suffer serious side effects, even sometimes death. If a patient’s genetic makeup is known beforehand, doctors can prescribe far more accurately so that there are fewer serious side effects.
But the serious ethical issues to be considered, such as reading individual genetic codes from DNA samples, affect both patients and the clinical staff who will have to introduce the new and complex technologies. Clinical staff experiences of these processes are also examined through interviews. Dr Lewis commented; "it is important to study how attitudes and perceptions change with the introduction of new medical technologies like pharmacogenetics, and that means studying the experiences of doctors and nursing staff as well as patients."
Dr Lewis added: "It's been known for a long time that an individual's genetic make-up affects the way they respond to medicines, both in terms of the likelihood of adverse side effects, and whether they respond to treatment. Pharmacogenetics, or so-called personalised medicine, offers the exciting possibility of individualised treatment.
"This could revolutionise medical care, giving doctors the ability to prescribe the best drug for their patient without trial and error.
"But there are major considerations – confidentiality, the impact of the genetic information on the patient, and the implications for their families.
"We need to understand how people will view this new development.
"There are also cost implications – is it worthwhile introducing pharmacogenetics? There is no real evidence yet from large-scale trials. We need to recognise that many other factors such as diet, lifestyle and age affect a patient's response to warfarin treatment."
The genetic profiling of patients taking part in the study will not influence their own treatment but will hopefully help future warfarin users.
The teams involved in the study will share £840,000 in research funding from the Department of Health.
Notes to editors:
- The study is part of the Department of Health's funding for research on genetics proposed in the 2003 White Paper 'Our inheritance, our future – realising the potential of genetics in the NHS'.
- Teams taking part are from the Universities of York, Liverpool, Newcastle and Birmingham plus the Wellcome Sanger Institute at Cambridge (connected with the UK end of the Human Genome Project), and Liverpool Broadgreen NHS Hospital Trust.
- The Science and Technology Studies Unit, in the Department of Sociology, is a specialist unit dedicated to rigorous analysis of the contemporary science and technology environment. It has an established international reputation as a centre of excellence in the sociology of science, knowledge and technology.
- This is the third study on pharmacogenetics or ‘personalised medicine’ SATSU has been funded to undertake.
- Professor Webster also directs the £5 million Innovative Health Technologies programme for the Economic and Social Research Council.