YPL1 – Issue 6 (March 1976)

The Data of Linguistics: Papers from the LAGB Autumn Conference, York 1975

Editors: John N. Green and Stephen J. Harlow
Philosophy of Science and the Data of Linguistics
Good Grammars of Good Theory of Language? A novel problem for the philosophy of science
9–20
Geoffrey Sampson
Download PDF
Languages are Clouds and Clocks
21–32
Terence Moore
Download PDF
On the Use of the Term System in Linguistics
33–44
Roger T. Bell
Abstract Download PDF

It has been commonplace in linguistics to accept as 'given' that language in some way constitutes a 'system' but very little effort has been put into the discovery of the type of system involved, the majority of linguists concentrating on the specification of the elements and linkages internal to the assumed system. Typically, language has been thought of, though rarely defined as, a 'closed system' similar in structure to those of the physical sciences. Such a view has led during this century to increasing reductionism, to the acceptance of the hypothetico-deductive approach to investigation of phenomena and to the adoption of models rooted in the axioms of symbolic logic and of mathematics.

In contrast, the social sciences have viewed their objects of study as 'open systems', interacting with, rather than isolated from, their environments. The distinction between these two types of system, derived from work in cybernetics in particular, can be seen to be of crucial importance to linguistics, since what is now required, as a result of sociolinguistic and psycholinguistic research, is a radical reorientation of the discipline to its data. It is now necessary to see language as an open system consisting of a virtually closed core but with several subsystems, so to speak on its periphery, which are very open and have strong degrees of connectedness with the systems which make up its environment. The task resolves itself into the creation of an adequate theory and explanatory model which reflects both the closed 'mechanical' aspects of the code itself and the open pattern and evolutionary aspects of the individual and social use of the code, and then links these two aspects in a systematic way through sets of statements connecting the inner form and the external functions of the overall system.

The paper has the following structure: an outline of the notions 'whole', 'system' and 'model' in the philosophy of science, the impact of these concepts on scientific method, the relationship of the terms to more common linguistic concepts such as langue and parole and their modern partial synonyms, the characteristics of 'closed' and 'open' systems in the sciences and, finally, a consideration of the relevance of 'systems thinking' to linguistics.

The Phonetician's Data
Variability in Phonetics
47–53
M.A.A. Tatham
Download PDF
The Semiotic Nature of Phonetic Data
55–62
John Laver
Download PDF
The Historical Linguist's Data
The Data of Historical Linguistics: Sources for the reconstruction of pronunciation from written records
65–73
Charles V.J. Russ
Download PDF
The Relevance of Comparative and Historical Data for the Description and Definition of a Language
75–87
R. Posner
Download PDF
Contextual Data and its Alternatives
The Role of the Concept of Text in the Elaboration of Linguistic Data
91–107
Jeffrey Ellis
Download PDF
Non-contextual Testing Procedures in Semantics
109–116
H. Eckert
Download PDF
Quantifying Context
117–129
Gerald Gazdar
Download PDF
The Linguist and His Informants
Formality in English: A non-linear scale as a descriptive alternative to labelled categories
133–148
R.S.K. Chan
Download PDF
Being Precise About Lexical Vagueness
149–165
Geoffrey N. Leech
Download PDF
The Mathematical Approach to Linguistic Data
The Relevance of Mathematical Linguistics to Empirical Linguistics
169–184
F.B. D'Agostino
Download PDF
Reviews
R. Lass and J.M. Anderson. Old English Phonology. Cambridge Studies in Linguistics 14. Cambridge University Press. 1975. xv + 326 pp. £10.25.
187–193
Richard M. Hogg
Download PDF
Derek Bickerton. Dynamics of a Creole System. Cambridge: CUP. 1975. vii + 224 pp.
195–199
Pauline Christie
Download PDF
H. Orton and N. Wright. A Word Geography of England. London–New York: Academic Press. 1975. xv + 302 pp + map of rivers, contours and chief cities. £9.50.
201–202
Charles V.J. Russ
Download PDF
T. Storer and D. Winter (eds). Formal Aspects of Cognitive Processes. Lecture Notes in Computer Science 22. Berlin: Springer-Verlag. 1975. v + 214 pp. DM 23.
203–204
P.D. Griffiths
Download PDF
P.H. Matthews. Morphology. An Introduction to the Theory of Word-Structure. Cambridge Textbooks in Linguistics. Cambridge University Press. 1974. 243 pp. £4.80 (hardcover) / £1.60 (paperback).
205–207
John Kelly
Download PDF
I. Robinson. The New Grammarians' Funeral: A critique of Noam Chomsky's linguistics. Cambridge University Press. 1975. xiv + 189 pp. £4.50.
209–211
John N. Green
Download PDF