We compared a Computerised Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CCBT) program (Stressbusters) with an attention control (self-help websites) for adolescent depression at referral to evaluate the clinical and cost-effectiveness of CCBT. We found that CCBT and self-help websites may both have a place in the care pathway for adolescents with depression.
Little was known about the value of implementing CCBT within the NHS for adolescents with low mood/depression. The software StressBusters, a computerised Cognitive Behaviour package based around eight 30 to 45 minute sessions designed specifically for 12 -18-year-olds was a potential intervention, but a trial was needed to establish if it was effective.
We carried out an initial feasibility study followed by a pilot RCT study to examined the clinical and cost-effectiveness of Stressbusters compared to an attention control (self-help websites). The main outcome was depression severity measured using the Short Beck Depression Inventory to collect data at baseline, then 4 and 12 months after completion of the intervention.
Our target population was 12-18-year-olds with low mood/depression living within the areas covered by a CAMHS service in a Northern City in England. One hundred and thirty-nine young people consented and were randomised.
Overall scores on outcome measures were not significantly different between the intervention and attention control groups at 12 months, however, both showed improvements on all measures. This may be because many young people improve as time progresses or because the website intervention yielded benefits to the young people that were just as helpful as CCBT.
The numerous challenges faced and present throughout all stages of the trial including its setup, recruitment period and delivery, have been reported to assist the planning of future such research.
Department of Health Sciences, University of York, York, UK
Limetrees Child, Adolescent and Family Unit, York
The research was funded by the NIHR Research for Patient Benefit (RfPB) programme (Award ID: PB-PG-0609-19295). The project was started in June 2011 and completed in August 2016.
Trial registration: ISRCTN31219579.